• Wet Scrubber
  • Heat Recuperators

Wet Scrubber

The heat contained in the exhaust air can be recovered in different ways. If the wet scrubber described on page 107, is operating with milk or whey as washing medium, an evaporation is achieved. The main purpose of a wet scrubber is of course to prevent air pollution by recovering the powder contained in the exhaust air. However, in the scrubber the exhaust air is cooled from the outlet temperature to the wet bulb temperature, i.e. to about 45șC, thus utilizing the heat for pre-evaporation of the milk before this enters into the evaporator. The effect of the wet scrubber on the total heat economy of the milk powder production line is substantial, and the savings together with product recovery are covering running costs inclusive of the relatively short return of the investment.

To explain the evaporation process an I-X diagram is used. See Fig. 97. The starting point is the condition of air entering the scrubber. This air will contain moisture partly due to the moisture always present in ambient air (usually 7 g/kg dry air) partly due to the evaporated water during the drying process (e.g. 42 g/kg dry air, as in the previous case with the two-stage spray dryer operated at 230șC, see page 139). The sum will be around 50 g moisture/kg dry air (point A). With an outlet temperature of the dryer/inlet temperature to the scrubber of 80șC and outlet temperature from the scrubber of 50șC, we will get a moisture content of 65 g/kg dry air (point B), as the curve will follow the adiabatic lines. The evaporation is therefore 65 g - 50 g = 15 g moisture/kg dry air.


Fig. 97 Humidity chart for air-water (set of adiabatic curves based on water of 45oC)

As we have about 42,000 kg/h air including the air from the Vibro-Fluidizer, we get an evaporation of about 630 kg/h corresponding to 3.5% of the total water evaporation in the dehydration system.

The heat savings are, however, achieved only if the wet scrubber can operate with the product as scrubbing medium which is the case with skim milk and whey. Water is used when whole milk powder is produced.

The temperature in the scrubber offers favourable conditions for bacterial contamination. The scrubber should therefore be used only when milk of first class is available. If the equipment is operated according to the instruction manual, which describes intermediate cleaning after 10 hours, the bacteriological activity will be minimal, as the retention time is considerably less than the generation time of the bacteria.

As it was the case with preheating with condensate, the wet scrubber offers a multiple advantage, as besides the heat recuperation it solves the pollution problem, and further the system has a substantial evaporation capacity. Part of the advantage is, however, lost again due to the needed intermediate cleaning after 10 hours. Use of wet scrubbers circulated with product is therefore not used very often in the industry.

The above mentioned systems for saving energy, apart from two-stage drying, have all required that the evaporator and spray dryer are operated at the same time. However, in some cases only the spray dryer is operated. Attempts have therefore been made to develop a heat recuperator for the spray dryer alone.

 

Heat Recuperators

The aim in a heat recuperator is to transfer the heat contained in the outlet air, having temperatures of 80-95șC, from the spray dryer and to utilize it e.g. to preheat the drying air. But it is also possible to use the recuperated heat to heat water for cleaning purposes or air for heating rooms. In the following only preheating of the drying air is discussed.

In principle, there are two different recuperating systems:

  • Air-to-Air
  • Air-Liquid-Air

Both systems are incorporated after the fines separator. However, incorporating a bag filter prior to the heat recuperator increases the efficiency, as deposits on the heat surface cannot be completely avoided even with correctly selected air velocities in the dust-loaded air. It is possible to operate the recuperator several days without cleaning, but should it prove necessary to clean the equipment, this is done by means of a built-in CIP system.

If the heat recuperator is designed to cool the outgoing air below the condensation temperature (depending upon moisture content per kilo dry air), also the condensation enthalpy is used for preheating. In this case a bag filter is installed prior to the heat re-cuperator to avoid deposits in the intermediate zone between the dry and wet area. Even bigger savings are then possible than the ones described below, which are all calculated without condensation.

Air-to-Air Heat Recuperator

In the heat recuperator type air-to-air, see Fig. 98, the drying air is preheated by means of the outgoing air passing counter-currently over the heat surface of the recuperator. This surface is formed as a number of tubes, inside of which the outgoing warm air is passing while the cold air is passing on the outside.


Fig. 98  Heat recuperator type air-to-air

The incorporation of this equipment in an existing plant may prove difficult and ex-pensive, as it may require large and long air ducts from which part of the recuperated energy is lost due to radiation, if the ducts are not insulated. In new installations it is easier to incorporate this type of heat recuperator, as the arrangement can be optimized with short air ducts.

The temperature to which the air can be preheated depends upon the temperature of the outgoing air. Therefore, this type of heat recuperator is most beneficial in combination with a one-stage spray dryer where the temperature of the outgoing air is high. The figures mentioned below are based upon a one-stage plant as mentioned in the table on page 139.

 Ambient air preheated from 10șC to 52șC
 Outgoing air cooled from 93șC to 51șC:
 
 Without Recuperator:

 
Fuel consumption: 175 kg/h
Electric energy consumption: 120 kW

corresponding to 1,595 Kcal/kg powder

 With Recuperator:

Fuel consumption: 140 kg/h
Electric energy consumption: 135 kW

corresponding to 1,305 Kcal/kg powder or a net saving of 18%.

Air-Liquid-Air Heat Recuperator

Another system, more flexible regarding the installation, is the air-liquid-air heat re-cuperator. This system is divided in two heat exchangers, in between which a heat transfer liquid is circulated, for example water.  If, due to low air temperatures during winter, it may be expected that the temperature of the water gets below zero, an anti-freeze agent is added to the water. As the heat transfer co-efficient is higher for air-liquid than for air-air, this system is more efficient than the air-to-air heat recuperator despite the fact that two heat surfaces are needed.

The heat transfer surface placed in the outgoing air is formed as a bundle of tubes inside which the dust-loaded air is passed. On the outside of the tubes the water streams counter-currently. The heat transfer surface placed in the inlet air is a normal finned tube heat exchanger. Water is recycled by means of a centrifugal pump.
If a recuperator of this type is installed in a one-stage spray dryer, the below mentioned heat savings are possible:

 Ambient air preheated from 10șC to 60șC
 Outgoing air cooled from 93șC to 44șC:
 
 Without Recuperator:

Fuel consumption: 175 kg/h
Electric energy consumption: 120 kW

corresponding to 1,595 Kcal/kg powder
 
 With Recuperator:

 
Fuel consumption: 130 kg/h
Electric energy consumption: 142 kW

corresponding to 1,225 Kcal/kg powder or a net saving of 23%.

If indirect oil- or gas-fired air heaters are used, the heat transfer liquid can - after the passage through the exhaust air heat exchanger - be passed through a heat exchanger placed in the combustion air duct, whereby even further savings can be achieved.

Download brochure in PDF-format
Click anywhere in this box to view and/or download the brochure in Adobe PDF format.

Sales support
If you have any questions regarding this product call
+61-3-98754000
or write an email to
General Contact Form
GEA Process Engineering Pty. Ltd.
A.B.N. 26 000 689 618 .
49 Railway Road - P.O. Box 42 Blackburn - Victoria 3130 - Australia
Tel +61-3-9875-4000 . Fax +61-3-9894-2205 . © 2008 GEA .
Contact

For US inquiries, please visit the Niro Inc website: www.niroinc.com



© GEA 2012